Fifteenth Finance Commission mired in controversy


The ruling BJP is continually seen as a celebration of North Indians despite all its efforts to create a Pan-India photograph. The controversy over the terms of reference of the fifteenth Finance Commission has simplest given credence to the sensation that it is a celebration of the Hindi speaking cow-belt. The modified population standards inside the 15th Finance Commission to keep in mind the 2011 census for arriving at populace weightage for devolution of an important budget as opposed to the earlier practice of 1971 census will actually benefit North Indian states that are ruled by way of BJP.

Commission mired in controversy

Even a state like Gujarat, most of the leaders in industrialization, has not done that nicely compared to a few southern states regarding social index and human aid development. This is because southern states, particularly Kerala, Tamil Nadu, and currently, Karnataka, have invested a big amount of cash in social improvement and training and health, resulting in population management. The demand for a separate Dravida Nadu has raised its ugly head because of this development. But that is true now, not justified, and southern states have to function to clear up this trouble sitting throughout the table with the imperative authorities.

Read More Article :

There is, however, a few advantage and justification inside the argument placed forth by way of Kerala, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, and Telangana that they’re being punished and meted out a step-motherly remedy for having executed relatively an awesome process in social and human useful resource improvement in the beyond three-4 decades. To pinnacle it all, this comes at a time whilst budget of some of the southern states like Tamil Nadu and Karnataka had been hit because of GST rollout, a destination-based totally oblique tax benefitting extra the consuming states rather than producing states. Andhra Pradesh has yet any other grouse – denial of unique class status, promised as part of the economic package within the face of bifurcation into Telangana and Andhra Pradesh. The mishandling of many of these issues by way of the important authorities has contributed to the growing North-South divide and intensification of political protests in South India over the fifteenth Finance Commission.

The previous 14th Finance Commission had raised the share of states round 32 in step with cent offered by the Thirteenth Finance Commission. It had performed this by way of shifting allocations to some of the relevant initiatives to states. This is a welcome development within the feel states have extra autonomy in spending assets in a number of the tasks, which in any other case used to be strictly monitored by the then Planning Commission. Inefficient states no longer get 2d and 1/3 tranches of the allocation for such projects launched without spending the primary tranche correctly within the exact centrally backed projects. This indirectly benefitted green and developed states, which were in Southern and Western regions. Implementation was once tardy in backward states, particularly in Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Bihar, and Madhya Pradesh, and consequently, social initiatives were no longer fully implemented there. As a result, the states might continue to be backward.

Commission mired in controversy

Reports suggest that with more allocation by using the 14th Finance Commission, these social improvement tasks still do not bridge sales deficits. This cash gets diverted in meeting wasteful expenditure on subsidies like delivery of unfastened power and so on; the advanced states like Maharashtra, Gujarat, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, and Haryana, however, are glad about the elevated allocation giving them greater headroom and autonomy to enforce the social improvement tasks that used to come with strings attached in advance. This is but any other trouble that the fifteenth Finance Commission will look at.

If southern states have done higher in social and human resource signs, it’s far because they are higher-administered states, and the politicians are less corrupt and feature a few commitments to the humans. In the sharp evaluation, the management in backward states is susceptible and corruption rampant, implementing developmental activities very tough. This is precisely the reason for the states no longer making ok development. By starving price range to those states that are doing nicely, the Centre might best be dispensing poverty in place of redistribution of wealth.

, A hit containing population growth via difficult work cannot be punished with reduced allocations. If Northern states have finished badly in this score, it’s miles because they have no longer spent the cash allocated to them accurately. Increased allocation to those north Indian states might be tantamount to worthwhile inefficiency. So the grouse of southern states is justified, and rightly Karnataka leader minister Siddaramaiah, DMK leader M K Stalin and Kerala finance minister Thomas Isaac were vocal on the problem and convened a meeting of southern states on April 10 to take the united stand at the pressing trouble.

According to V Bhaskar, who changed into the joint secretary of Thirteenth Finance Commission, Uttar Pradesh gains Rs 35,167 crore if the 2011 populace census becomes taken into consideration, even as Andhra Pradesh will lose Rs 24,340 crore. Likewise, Bihar, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh profits Rs 32,044 crore, Rs 25,468 crore, and Rs 14,735 crore. Tamil Nadu, Kerala, and Karnataka will lose Rs 22,497 crore, Rs 20,285 crore, and Rs eight,373 crores. This is exactly the purpose that right from the 7th Finance Commission, the statutory frame is remitted to take 1971 population for computing kingdom’s percentage. Even Parliament seats are constant on those criteria. If the criteria are implemented to Parliament seats as nicely in destiny, then southern states may be an increasing number of marginalized, politically in addition to fiscally. Prime Minister Narendra Modi claims to be a votary of cooperative federalism and but the important government has asked the fifteenth Finance Commission to recollect the 2011 census without consulting states, especially southern states, which has a proper fear.